Happiness has been a hot topic in business lately and I’ve been delighted to see such a serious subject get the attention it deserves in the corner office. In the Jeffersonian tradition, the “pursuit of happiness” is considered an inalienable right on par with life and liberty. Yet, until recently, managers here and elsewhere in the world made little effort to rigorously measure or manage happiness.
That was part of the reason I created the Net Promoter score (NPS) nine years ago. When I was considering various names for the new metric, I thought seriously about calling it the Net Happiness Score. We describe NPS as a measure of loyalty, but the overarching objective of the framework is to make people happy—so happy that they recommend a product or company to friends and loved ones so they can benefit from a similar experience.
But even today we still maintain a not-so-subtle link between NPS and happiness through the emoticons we use to report the scores. For example, we communicate a Net Promoter Score of 75 with a wall of faces like this:
It’s pretty hard to miss the link between NPS and the emotional energy of happy or unhappy people when looking at a picture like this. Using emoticons to represent promoters, passives and detractors requires little additional explanation. What’s more, the happy, passive and angry faces illustrate that making people happy and earning their loyalty creates emotional outcomes, not just economic ones.
In 2004, Charles Schwab Corporation was in such bad shape that the board asked its recently retired founder, Chuck Schwab, to return as CEO. He came back to a company that wasn’t just in financial trouble, but one that he felt was treating clients poorly.
Chuck Schwab had always tried to make a focus on clients part of the company’s DNA, and in December 2005, I was asked to talk to 600 of the company’s leaders. Shortly afterwards, the company put the Net Promoter framework at the core of its change efforts and began a massive—and ultimately successful—turnaround, which we describe in detail in The Ultimate Question 2.0.
Wharton marketing professor Peter Fader interviewed me recently about The Ultimate Question 2.0. Fader is co-director of The Wharton Customer Analytics Initiative, and recently wrote his own book on customer centricity, so as you might expect, he asked me some really thoughtful questions. You can read a transcript of the interview, or watch it here:
————
Sign up for our monthly email newsletter, Loyalty Insights, for a step-by-step guide to installing a Net Promoter® system at your company
While in Toronto, I was also invited for an interview on BNN, one of Canada’s leading business networks. Host Frances Horodelski asked me “Why isn’t everybody doing this? Why isn’t everybody saying if I keep my customers happy, if I treat them like kings, I’ll get more customers and my business will grow?”
Great question, Frances. Of course, more and more companies are saying just that. You can watch the full interview here:
Listen in on MBA classes and corporate conferences and you will hear a lot of talk about the need for inspiring missions, ethical behavior and transcendent purpose. And judging from the “core values” statements in most annual reports, the vast majority of business leaders want their companies to grow by enriching the lives of their customers and employees.
And yet, this can often sound like so much fluff in the real business world. Our system of financial accounting rewards quarterly profits, but struggles mightily to place a value on ethical behavior. Even accounting rules specifically dealing with reputation — goodwill and intangible assets — are subject to frequent rule changes and endless debate. Continue reading →
Most companies claim they want enthusiastic, engaged employees — and with good reason. Employee engagement and financial performance are connected. A recent study by Aon Hewitt, for example, found that companies with high levels of engagement outperformed the stock market in 2010.
And yet Gallup research indicates that more than 70 percent of employees in the typical company are “not engaged” or “actively disengaged.”
What’s the reason for this failure? In my view, it boils down to a startling disconnect between how companies try to promote engagement and what truly inspires and motivates employees. Continue reading →
I travel a lot, as do many of the executives I talk to. So when I give a speech and ask audience members to describe the last time they told their friends to avoid doing business with a company, airlines provide a reliable source of horror stories.
In 2010, a team at KLM set out to experiment with delivery of tiny gifts — more demonstrations of commitment and recognition than anything of significant value — to customers who had made public their travel plans via a Twitter posting. For seven weeks, employees of the airline scoured Twitter for examples of passengers about to board flights who were signalling their travel plans. In some cases, Foursquare was the vehicle the passengers had used to communicate their plans.
In each case, once the team identified a passenger, they did a little research. What else could they learn through quick review of their Twitter profile, information they had posted on Facebook, or other traces they had left through public postings. They garnered information that would let them personalize a small gift so that it would demonstrate real interest and be meaningful to that person, in particular. Continue reading →
More and more companies are tying incentive pay to customer metrics. TIAA-CREF, the big financial services company, includes customer loyalty score improvement in senior executive compensation. Phones4U, a UK mobile phone retailer, announced a big increase in the weight of Net Promoter scores in its frontline pay plan. Pep Boys, a US auto parts store chain, reports in its proxy statement that customer metrics are now an important part of its executive compensation system. And Enterprise Rent-A-Car links its Enterprise Service Quality index customer feedback scores to promotions.
The payoff from linking incentives to customer feedback can be significant. But before you make such a move, help yourself avoid the pitfalls and risks described in my earlier post by meeting five preconditions: Continue reading →
If you’re serious about creating a customer-driven culture, then you will certainly tie incentive compensation to customer feedback. Right?
Wrong.
Everyone knows incentive compensation can really focus people’s attention. Done right, it can reinforce a company’s values. It can spur creativity and accelerate actions designed to meet important goals.
When it’s done wrong, however, the unintended consequences can be devastating — which is exactly what happens when some companies try to link compensation to customer feedback. Here are three big risks: Continue reading →
My personal e-mail inbox currently holds requests for feedback from twelve different companies: a couple of hotels, two web-based retailers, a credit-card company, an investment management firm, etc. As a customer experience expert, I often advise companies on gathering and using customer feedback, so you might think I’d be interested in these surveys. But I’ve glanced at the ones cluttering my inbox, and I’m not even going to fill out most of them. Continue reading →
Rob Markey and I had the pleasure of speaking with Intuit CEO Brad Smith this week in preparation for our upcoming NPS CEO roundtable. (The roundtable will be taking place in late September, so keep an eye out for video highlights shortly thereafter.) We asked Brad if he could comment on some of the benefits Intuit has achieved with the Net Promoter system.
His response warmed our hearts: “In my 25 years of experience in business, I have never seen a more powerful approach.” Brad explained why Net Promoter is so powerful for Intuit: “NPS breaks down the silos and organizational boundaries so everyone can focus on the customer. From the board of directors and external audiences all the way to product engineers and frontline phone reps, NPS helps drive our culture toward our True North. It helps us stay on mission—to be a growth company that improves people’s lives.” Continue reading →
A blogger who calls herself BirdAbroad found a Chinese store that looked almost exactly like one of Apple’s iconic retail outlets, complete with winding staircase, walls lined with Apple products, and employees dressed in blue T-shirts and Apple name tags. The problem? The store was in the southwestern city of Kunming. The only stores Apple has opened in China so far are in Beijing and Shanghai.
Before long, diligent researchers were uncovering other apparently fake (shanzhai) Apple stores elsewhere in China. The whole episode became a case study of the difficulty of protecting trademarks and other intellectual property in that country.
Our suspicion is that a little comparison shopping between real Apple stores and fake ones would be enormously revealing — because there’s one part of an Apple store that you can’t fake: authentic commitment to customers. Continue reading →
In 2006, GE began building incentives around improved Net Promoter Scores in its businesses. Many other companies followed suit. Yet, few have gotten it right. In fact, we have heard many reports of gaming, exclusive focus on the scores and other problems. Several months ago, in a post on this topic, I described the challenges companies face when they tie incentives to customer feedback. This post will tackle “pre-conditions” to meet before you move forward.
Interest in tying incentives to NPS and other customer metrics continues. Since at least 2008, TIAA-CREF, the big insurance company, has included NPS improvement goals in senior executive compensation. In May 2010, Phones4U, a UK mobile phone retailer, announced a big increase in the weight of NPS in its frontline compensation (news article). The move received mixed reviews from sales staff. Pep Boys, a US auto parts store chain, reports that NPS is an important part of its executive compensation system, and describes it in its proxy statement.
The obvious question: How do you avoid the most serious pitfalls and risks? Continue reading →
Fred and Rob discussed the upcoming book in a July 20 webinar. In this and subsequent posts, they answer additional audience questions from the webinar question-and-answer session.
Q: Could you comment on what you are doing in applying a Net Promoter system approach to the nonprofit sector?
Several nonprofits have adopted the Net Promoter system. Typically a nonprofit will have several constituencies where Net Promoter can help foster better relationships. For example, a nonprofit needs to earn the loyalty of: Continue reading →